Definitions, in R
Record both excursions relative to the risk you defined at entry, not in currency or pips. Doing it in R makes a gold trade and an index trade directly comparable.
risk = |entry − first stop| MFE (R) = best price in your favour, distance from entry ÷ risk MAE (R) = worst price against you, distance from entry ÷ risk realised R = (exit − entry) ÷ risk (long; invert for short) efficiency = realised R ÷ MFE
Exit efficiency is the payoff metric: it tells you what share of the move that was available you actually captured.
How to capture it without extra work
You do not need tick data. When you close a trade, glance at the chart and note the extreme in each direction — one number each. Every trade in Simple Trading Journal has optional Max MFE (R) and Max MAE (R) fields for exactly this, and it takes about five seconds per trade.
Give it 30–50 trades per strategy before drawing conclusions. Below that, you are reading noise.

